Stock Market

How to Value an IPO Using Peer Comparison

22 November 2026By Jaspreet Kaur6 views
How to Value an IPO Using Peer Comparison

Suppose a friend sends you an IPO link. The price band says Rs 1865 to Rs 1960 per share and he asks ‘Is that cheap?. You look through the number. Honestly, nobody can say. A price on its own means nothing.

That's the whole problem with IPO valuation. A Rs 100 share can be expensive and a Rs 5,000 share can be a bargain. What matters is what you get for your money. The easiest way to find out is peer comparison. You check what similar listed companies are worth and see where the new one fits. We'll show you how, in plain words, with one real IPO and no finance degree needed.

Peer comparison = valuing an IPO by comparing it with similar companies that are already listed on the stock exchange.

The tool = a ratio such as P/E. If similar companies trade at 25 times their profit, a new company with similar profit and growth should fetch something close.

It's also called comparable company analysis, or "comps" for short. It's the most common method in IPO analysis. It's also the backbone of IPO pricing, because a new company has no share price history of its own to look at.

Think of a listed peer as a measuring tape. Hold it against the new company and you can see at a glance whether the price runs long or short.

Start with an example of a flat, not a stock

Forget stocks for a minute. Say you're buying a flat in your society.

The broker quotes Rs 1.2 crore for a 1000 sq ft flat. Is that fair? You can't tell. So you ask what similar flats in the same building sold for. Three recent ones went at Rs 9,000, Rs 10,000 and Rs 11,000 per sq ft. The middle rate is Rs 10,000. For 1,000 sq ft, that works out to Rs 1 crore.

Now check what broker quoted for the same unit. Rs 1.2 crore ÷ 1,000 sq ft comes to Rs 12,000 per sq ft. Against the neighbours' middle rate of Rs 10,000 which is actually 20% higher. Is the broker mad? Maybe not because a park view or a fresh renovation can justify this premium amount but a noisy road facing the window can't.

That's peer comparison. The flat is the new company. The neighbours are listed companies in the same business. The price per sq ft is a ratio like P/E. The broker's asking price is the IPO price band.

Comparable company analysis in four simple steps

  1. Pick the peers. Choose 3 - 6 listed companies in the same business with a similar size and similar customers. A car maker should be compared with car makers, not with a bank.

  2. Pick the ratio. Most often it's the price-to-earnings ratio, or P/E. It tells you how many rupees investors pay for every Rs 1 of yearly profit. A P/E of 25x means Rs 25 for Rs 1 of profit.

  3. Find the peer range. Collect the ratio for each peer. Then note the average and the median, which is simply the middle value.

  4. Apply it to the IPO company. Multiply the peer ratio by the company's profit per share, known as EPS. That gives you an implied price. Compare it with the IPO price band.

Here's the only formula you need. P/E = share price ÷ EPS. EPS or earnings per share, is simply a company's yearly profit divided by its number of shares. Hyundai Motor India, for example, earned Rs 6,060 crore in FY24 (the financial year ended March 2024) across about 81.25 crore shares. That works out to Rs 74.58 per share. Flip the formula around and you get share price = P/E × EPS.

That's the whole recipe with four steps and a formula. Can work well for a first-pass IPO valuation.

IPO Valuation Step by Step, Using Hyundai Motor India 

Let's run the four steps on Hyundai Motor India, whose IPO opened in October 2024. The price band was Rs 1865 to Rs 1960 and the final price was Rs 1960. All figures below are as reported around the issue.

Step 1. The listed car makers in its offer document were Maruti Suzuki, Mahindra & Mahindra and Tata Motors.

Step 2. We'll use P/E.

Step 3. Here's how the peers looked.

Company

P/E (x)

Maruti Suzuki

29.4

Mahindra & Mahindra

30.0

Tata Motors

11.4

Peer average

23.6

Peer median

29.4

See Tata Motors? At 11.4x it drags the average down. It's a far more mixed business, so it isn't a clean match. That's why many analysts lean on the median. One odd number can't throw it off.

Step 4. You already know Hyundai's FY24 EPS, which is Rs 74.58. Now multiply.

Benchmark

P/E (x)

Implied price for Hyundai

Peer average

23.6

About Rs 1,760

Peer median

29.4

About Rs 2,190

Actual IPO price

26.3

Rs 1,960

The IPO price landed inside the range. Hyundai asked for about 10% less than Maruti Suzuki's P/E, which valued the company at roughly Rs 1.6 lakh crore.

So, was the price fair? In Hyundai’s favour, it earned more profit on every Rs 100 of sales than Maruti and made better use of its shareholders’ money. Against it, Maruti held about 41% of India’s car market while Hyundai held about 15%. Many felt a company that was much smaller should have been priced well below Maruti, not just 10% below. On listing day, the shares came in at Rs 1931 on the BSE, slightly under the issue price of Rs 1960 

Remember a valuation is a map, not a forecast. It shows you the neighbourhood. It doesn't promise the view.

So pick any IPO you've b

een curious about. Find its peers in the offer document, grab their P/Es and run the four steps. You'll be surprised how quickly it clicks.

Which yardstick fits the business?

P/E is the favourite but it isn't the only tool. Pick the one that fits the business.

Ratio

What it tells you

Use it when

P/E

The price paid for Rs 1 of yearly profit

The company earns steady profit

EV/EBITDA

The value of the whole business against its operating profit

Peers carry very different debt levels

EV/Sales (also P/S)

The value against revenue

The company is loss-making or early stage

P/B

The price against net assets

Banks and finance companies

For a feel of the numbers, Hyundai's price band worked out to about 26x P/E, 16.5x EV/EBITDA and 2.3x price to sales on FY24 figures. In case EBITDA is new to you, it's the profit a business makes from its operations before interest, tax and depreciation. If you're just starting out, stick with P/E and treat the other rows as bonus material.

Loss-making companies need a different tool. Swiggy reported a loss per share in FY24, so a P/E would be meaningless. For firms like that, investors turn to sales multiples.

Watch out: pick the yardstick that suits the business, not the one that flatters the IPO.

Why a peer is never a perfect twin

Even your closest neighbour has a different floor plan. Companies are no different. So treat the peer number as a starting line and put a few questions to the IPO company before you trust it.

Is it growing faster than its peers? If yes, it can deserve a richer multiple. Does it keep more of each rupee of sales as profit? Better margins usually earn a premium. How big is it? A leader with 41% market share and a challenger with 15% don't carry the same risk. And how much debt is it hauling around? Heavy loans make profits wobbly.

Then there's geography. Korean carmakers traded at P/Es of 4x to 5x at the time. Hyundai's Indian unit was priced above 26x. Same brand and same cars, but a very different growth story.

One more thing worth knowing. Bankers often shave a little off the price compared with listed peers, so fresh buyers have a reason to show up. That small discount is a normal part of IPO pricing.

Treat the peer range as a zone, never a single dot on the map.

Five ways beginners get IPO analysis wrong

Almost everyone trips on these at first. Here's how to step around them.

  1. Comparing apples with oranges. A bank isn't a car maker. Stay inside the same business.

  2. Falling in love with one ratio. A stock can look cheap on P/E and pricey on EV/EBITDA. Check at least two.

  3. Mixing years. FY24 profit next to a peer's FY25 price gives you nonsense. Keep the periods matched.

  4. Letting one odd number steer. Remember Tata Motors at 11.4x? That's exactly why the median exists.

  5. Mistaking "cheaper than peers" for "bargain". The peers themselves may be overpriced. Relative value is only relative.

Fix the peer list first and the rest get a lot easier.

Where the peer numbers hide

Good news. The hard digging is already done for you, and it's all public. Here's the treasure map.

First, open the red herring prospectus (RHP), the detailed offer document a company publishes before its IPO. Scroll to the section called "Basis for Offer Price". Older documents say "Basis for Issue Price". That's where the company shows its own EPS and P/E and lines them up against listed peers.

Next, study the peer table. Notice who the company picked and, just as important, who it left out.

Then refresh the numbers. Peer share prices move every day, so check each peer's current P/E on the stock exchange website or a free screener.

Last, work out your own median. Five minutes in a spreadsheet will do.

Pro tip: the company has already drafted the peer list for you. Your job is to question it.

One level deeper

Three questions readers often ask us.

What exactly is EV? It's the price tag for buying the whole business. Take the market value of the shares, add its debt and subtract its cash.

Is this the only way to value a company? No. A discounted cash flow (DCF) model forecasts future cash and works backwards. Comps look at market prices instead. Bankers usually run both and see where they agree. 

What are precedent transactions? A cousin of comps. Instead of today's share prices, you look at what buyers paid when similar companies were acquired.

Here are the five things to remember:

-Price means nothing until you set it beside similar listed companies.

-Choose close (similar) peers, a ratio that fits and the median. Then multiply by the company's own EPS.

-Hyundai's IPO sat at 26.3x P/E, roughly 10% below Maruti Suzuki's 29.4x.

-No peers are the same. Adjust them for growth, margins, size and risk.

-Peer comparison shows you the neighbourhood. It can't call listing day.

FAQs

Q1. What is peer comparison in IPO valuation?

It means valuing a company that's about to list by comparing it with similar companies that are already trading. You look at ratios such as P/E and see whether the IPO price sits close to the peers or far from them.

Q2. What is comparable company analysis?

It's the formal name for the same idea. Analysts call it "comps". It uses the market value of similar listed companies to estimate what a company is worth.

Q3. Which ratio is best for IPO valuation?

There's no single best one. P/E suits profitable companies. EV/EBITDA helps when debt levels differ. EV/Sales works for loss-making businesses and P/B suits banks.

Q4. How is IPO pricing decided?

The company and the banks running the issue, called lead managers, set a price band using valuation work such as peer comparison. The final price is then settled through book building, a process where investors place bids and the price follows the demand.

Q5. Can a beginner do IPO analysis without a finance background?

Yes. Pick the peers, choose one ratio, find the median and multiply it by the company's EPS. The offer document gives you most of the numbers.

Q6. What if a company has no listed peers?

Use the closest businesses, including overseas ones, and adjust for differences in market, size and growth. Treat the result with extra caution.

One last thing before you hit apply

This blog is for learning and isn't investment advice.

Numbers get friendlier when someone walks you through them. Since 2009, more than 51,000 students have learned finance with us at The WallStreet School. Our Financial Modeling, CFA and Value Investing courses teach you to build and question valuations just like the one you've just read. If you'd like to value your next IPO with a mentor beside you, talk to our counselling team before you decide. They'll point you to the right starting line.

Contact us at www.thewallstreetschool.com

Interested in Learning Finance Professionally?

Our courses take you from fundamentals to expert level — with live mentors and placement support.

Explore Our Courses
Call Us Now
Chat
How to Analyse Quarterly Results: 5-Step Guide